Clayton & Clayton
Afternoon sunlight grazes gray cedar shingles, a white glazed entry door and weathered boards on a raised covered porch.

After Bathing Hours, Normandy Beach Turns Into a Surf Fishery

In November, the people at the waterline in Normandy Beach are surfcasters waiting on the striped bass migration, and the best record of the run comes from a bait shop that has been on Route 35 since 1962.

The beach and its dunes

The Normandy Beach Improvement Association's beach rules start by saying the beaches are private and run "for the benefit of its membership." In summer, the association keeps tight control. Bathing hours run from 10 a.m. to 5 p.m. Everyone 12 and older needs a badge during those hours, and badges are sold at the Bay Beach House at Broad and Seventh Avenue.

The same page warns against crossing the dunes or damaging dune plants at any time of year.

The front desk at 485 Route 35 North

The fall run on this part of the island is tracked from Charlie's Bait and Tackle at 485 Route 35 North, directly across the lot from Charlie's Farm Market. The shop goes back to Ernie Wuesthoff, who opened it in 1962, according to a 2010 Star-Ledger report on NJ.com. Its listing with The Fisherman says that besides tackle, it sells jewelry, sea shells, shark's teeth and nautical decor.

The shop's weekly reports to The Fisherman read like a logbook for the beach. Two of them, a week apart, cover the stretch between the September nor'easter and the start of November.

Where the run stood in late October

On October 19, Philly Billy at the shop reported that rainbait had been "choking the cuts and sloughs," with a couple of bluefish chasing it. Blackfish fishing in the canal was solid, and everyone was "waiting for the first shot of stripers to push in," which could happen any day with the cool nights. A second report that day said bunker schools were holding tight to the beach while bass showed little interest in them, though surfcasters were picking up a few stripers on lures.

The October 26 reports filled in more of the picture:

  • Water temperature. The water was around 60 degrees, and the stripers still hadn't moved in. Anglers were finding a few fish at night in the back bays and rivers, and blackfish were biting at the inlet on green crabs.
  • The canal. Wind pushed most of the shop's regulars into the canal the week before. Pete at the shop said "every day they're getting a keeper over there," with blackfish, striped bass and bluefish all biting. Shrimp worked when green crabs ran out, and eels worked at slack tide.
  • The beach. Bunker showed up off the beach on Saturday, October 24, with no fish by day and a few on plugs overnight into Sunday. On Sunday afternoon, a fleet of boats worked bunker slicks off Brick.
  • The outlook. "I hope it blows up this week," Pete told The Fisherman. He pointed to the offshore winds forecast for the start of the week and Monday's full moon as what could set off the bite.

As of October 26, the bait was along the beach and the water was cooling, but the bass were still to the north. Pete mentioned that "a lot of guys are heading up north as far as Rockaway, NY."

The beach the fish are coming back to

The cuts and sloughs in those reports are on a beach that took a storm a few weeks earlier. A New Jersey Department of Environmental Protection storm assessment dated October 2, 2026 covers a nor'easter that hit mainly from September 25 through 28, after four days of moderate to strong northeast winds. State coastal engineers inspected the shoreline from September 28 through 30.

For the Toms River stretch from Normandy Beach through Monterey Beach, the memo records up to 60 feet of sloped beach erosion, wind-blown sand building up on the dunes, and wave runup reaching the upper beach and dune. DEP rated the damage minor.

The neighboring towns put that 60 feet in perspective:

Reach Sloped beach erosion Other findings DEP rating
Bay Head Up to 60 ft Vertical dune scarp up to 8 ft; crossover damage between Karge St. and Johnson St. Major
Mantoloking Up to 100 ft Wind-blown sand on dunes; scarping and crossover damage at Downer Ave. Minor
Brick Up to 50 ft Wind-blown sand on dunes; runup to upper beach/dune Minor
Toms River, Normandy Beach through Monterey Beach Up to 60 ft Wind-blown sand on dunes; runup to upper beach/dune Minor

Bay Head lost about the same amount of beach but was rated major because its dunes were cut into an eight-foot scarp. Normandy Beach's dunes picked up wind-blown sand instead. Across the state, DEP inspected 81 reaches of coast and rated 53 minor, 18 moderate and 10 major. Normandy Beach was one of the better-off reaches, with a flatter beach in front of dunes that came through the storm intact.

Surf Turkey, the week of Thanksgiving

The shop's calendar builds to its 15th annual Surf Turkey tournament, held over Thanksgiving week, and by October 19 the shop reported that everyone was gearing up for it. These are the details as The Fisherman published them:

Detail Surf Turkey 2026
Dates Wednesday, Nov. 25, 5 a.m., through Saturday, Nov. 28, 5 p.m.
Format Surfcasters only, catch and release
Entry fee $45
Prizes First- and second-longest striped bass, plus a five-fish stringer
Guaranteed award At least $2,000 for the longest single striper
Boundaries South jetty of Manasquan Inlet to north jetty of Barnegat Inlet
Awards Saturday night at Used to Be's Island Eatery, Mantoloking
Contact Pete at the shop, 732-793-1144

The tournament covers the whole beach from Manasquan Inlet down to Barnegat Inlet, with Normandy Beach in between and the shop on Route 35 as the place to sign up. Because it's catch and release, every fish entered goes back in the water.

The rules behind the counter

The state and township rules for the season are all published, and the sources are linked here.

  1. Size and bag limit. The 2026 New Jersey Fish & Wildlife Marine Digest sets the Atlantic Ocean limit at one striped bass between 28 and 31 inches, with no closed season. The Digest also says regulations stay in effect until changed.
  2. No change at the federal level for 2026. In October 2025, the Atlantic States Marine Fisheries Commission's Addendum III kept recreational measures where they were instead of adopting a proposed cut, and it set January 1, 2027 as the deadline for a new size-measurement method.
  3. Circle hooks with bait. DEP requires non-offset circle hooks when fishing for striped bass with bait. An artificial lure with bait attached is exempt.
  4. Free registration. Anglers 16 and older fishing recreationally in New Jersey's marine or tidal waters must sign up with the free New Jersey Saltwater Recreational Registry.
  5. Driving on the beach in Toms River. The township code allows four-wheel-drive vehicles on the ocean beach from October 1 through May 14 with a permit. The code lists the fee as $25 per vehicle, but that section dates to 2012. Vehicles enter and exit only at Harding Avenue or Second Avenue in Ortley Beach and are banned from bayfront beaches year-round.
  6. Island Beach State Park. The park to the south issues its own mobile sport fishing vehicle permits. Annual permits cost $195 for New Jersey residents and $225 for nonresidents. Three-day permits cost $75 and $90 and are available October 1 through December 31. Weekday-only permits cost $150 and $175 and are good seven days a week during that same window.

This is general information, not legal advice. Fees and rules change, so check with the issuing agency before relying on them.

At Clayton & Clayton, we've watched these fall seasons from Bay Head since 1930. We know an oceanfront house on this island is used in November as well as July. If you'd like to talk about owning, renting out or keeping a home where the off-season revolves around the striper run, schedule a confidential consultation.

Work With Us

Our dedicated team serves our clients with integrity and respect, providing innovative marketing, their expertise of the real estate market and local connections to build lasting relationships. Contact us today to find out how we can be of assistance to you!

Follow Me on Instagram